Why Electronic Health Records Aren't More Usable
Chet Van Wert | Apr 13, 2016
Topic category: Connected Healthcare

There is no doubt that Electronic Health Records (EHR) are essential to the future of healthcare. They'll provide more complete patient information; less friction recording, accessing and sharing information; and better security. Unfortunately, the ecosystem in which EHRs exist hasn't yet evolved the standards and best practices that are necessary to using them effectively.

How did we get to today's dysfunctional environment? Less than half of electronic health records (EHR) vendors that reported on their development processes employed standard user-centered design (UCD) methods in developing their systems. An even smaller number tested the usability of their systems with physicians - a key segment of the target market.

As a result, doctors spend up 9 times longer completing an EHR, much of it entering required but irrelevant data, as compared with an old-fashioned hand-written record. Doesn’t sound like a formula for reducing costs, does it? Add to this sorry situation a lack of format and process standards that make EHRs from different vendors incompatible, and you have a sense of the mess that EHRs represent today.

Ken Terry, writing for CIO.com, sees the cause of this mess in a development process that prioritized billing issues over clinical usability. Another source of conflicting priorities is government regulations:

"EHRs were easier to use before developers were required to design them in a way that enables them to collect quality data for the government's EHR incentive program. (Physician practices and hospitals must gather this data on health care processes for a certain percentage of Medicare or Medicaid patients to show "meaningful use" of EHRs so they can qualify for incentives and/or avoid financial penalties.)

"Another downside of the meaningful use program, says Basch, who advises the American College of Physicians on health IT, is that vendors have had to focus on rewriting their software to meet the changing EHR certification criteria. As a result, they have had little bandwidth left over to meet the needs of their customers by building more user-centered products."

EHRs in use today are essentially a first-generation product, with all the problems that implies. Records designed with primary care physicians in mind are cumbersome for specialists to use, and many of the smart functions one could imagine an EHR performing have yet to be developed. Of course, changing regulations don't help, either, as they monopolize developers' time that might otherwise be spent improving the product's usability

In 2014, the American Medical Association published a framework for an improving EHR usability, which state that EHRs should meet the following criteria:

  1. enhance physicians' ability to provide high-quality patient care
  2. support team-based care
  3. promote care coordination
  4. offer product modularity and configurability
  5. reduce cognitive workload
  6. promote data liquidity
  7. facilitate digital and mobile patient engagement
  8. expedite user input into product design and post-implementation feedback
Ken Terry |Dec 3, 2015
Tags: electronic health record, EHR, healthcare IT, healthcare technology, EHR usability, electronic health record usability
comments powered by Disqus
Avaya's smart communications solutions help healthcare providers realize the potential of electronic health records
Avaya's SDN Fx: How to Implement the Internet of Things for Healthcare

Connected devices represent both a unique kind of opportunity and a critical security problem for healthcare providers. Avaya's SDN Fx enables connectivity among medical devices and healthcare staff that is both easy to implement and secure. With SDN Fx healthcare providers can:

Deliver New Innovation Fast

Deploying thousands of innovative devices faster and more securely can seem nearly impossible. SDN Fx Healthcare provides the simplicity you need to automatically connect, help secure, and manage the ever-growing number of technologies available.

Achieve Greater Efficiency and Lower Costs

The concept of the Internet of Things for Healthcare promises greater efficiency for medical professionals and supporting staff. Make it reality with SDN Fx Healthcare, which provides affordable, cost-effective infrastructure that reduces complexity and increases security.

Focus Your IT Resources Strategically

IT organizations typically spend too much time performing manual tasks—known as “just keeping the lights on.” SDN Fx Healthcare lets IT organizations cut time spent on repetitive tasks and troubleshooting.

Delivering on the promise of distributed networking for healthcare
4 Imperatives for Mobile Medical Professionals

Medical professionals need ubiquitous access to information and technology. But security and network constraints are often roadblocks. Avaya identifies four critical technology elements that can help the mobile medical professional.

Information mobility and the evolution of healthcare
Healthcare in the Era of the Internet of Things

The Internet of Things holds great promise to improve our health and wellbeing, from connected medical devices to instant and automatic data sharing, to more complete record keeping.

Hackers continue to dominate the headlines. Healthcare providers hold some of the world’s most sensitive information, making them a particularly high-value target.

Reporters at Computerworld recently demonstrated the risk of “medjacking,” where hackers were able to exploit Internet-connected medical devices, such as infusion pumps, to administer deadly levels of an otherwise helpful drug into an unsuspecting patient, without triggering an alarm to medical professionals.

The network represents one of the largest avenues of attack, and every possible effort should be made to secure it.

Software-defined networking represents a crucial layer in a multi-layered security plan. The network can be easily segmented into areas that remain invisible to devices on the edge. One physical network can create numerous virtual networks on the fly. Network connections open as approved devices connect, and dynamically close as those devices are disconnected. Getting a complete picture of every device on the network at that moment is a single click away.

In a healthcare setting, does the network that transports data from the MRI machine to the electronic health record system need to share the same path options as the payment card system? No. By segmenting the network and isolating various systems, you create additional protections against a single intrusion infecting multiple systems.

To quote the lead hacker at the NSA, who recently gave a presentation on how companies can protect themselves from the NSA: “Segment networks and important data to make it harder for hackers to reach your jewels.”

Tapping the promise while managing the risks
Sydney Adventist Hospital Uses Avaya Connectivity to Ensure Patient Information Keeps Flowing

Sydney Adventist Hospital is a busy hospital, admitting 20,000 patients annually.

With that level of activity, doctors and staff need to access patient records, on every kind of device, at any time of day or night. How do they do it? With Avaya’s strong, stable network. Here are Sydney Adventist Hospital’s own words:

  • “The core network has remained the same since 2002 and been “rock solid,” according to Chris Williams, Chief Information Officer, SAH.
  • “Avaya switch clustering provides links to all parts of the network – if one link fails, the rest keep the hospital’s information flowing.”
  • “Plug and play provisioning allows a new user to be set up within one minute by simply plugging a phone into the switch.”
  • “We’re consistently impressed with the reliability and performance of Avaya networking products.”
  • “The Avaya access solution provides an energy saving of up to 50% compared to competitors’ solutions.”

Your healthcare organization's effectiveness is a matter of smart communication.

It’s all a matter of smart communications

Bedside Software-Defined Networking and the Evolution of Healthcare IT

IT organizations are faced with something Zeus Kerravala of ZK Research calls a Complexity Chasm. It’s been forming for decades and is becoming problematic for healthcare providers. Learn how applying a Software-Defined Networking model for the network edge can close the Complexity Chasm and help IT organizations enable the latest healthcare innovations securely and simply.

It's Time for Healthcare IT To Evolve